🎉Community Raffle - Win $25

An exclusive raffle opportunity for active members like you! Complete your profile, answer questions and get your first accepted badge to enter the raffle.
Join and Win

Explanation for very large maximum constraint violation % in the first iteration

User: "pshivashankar"
Altair Community Member
Updated by pshivashankar

Greetings,

 

I am performing a free-size optimization (iteration summary given below) and trying to understand the explanation behind maximum constraint violation %. So far the following is clear:

  • If constraint violation > 1% : status is V (violated)
  • If constraint violation < 1% : status is A (Active)
  • Large constraint violation % could mean that the constraint is too tight and that the problem itself is ill-defined.
  • the difference  between regular and soft convergence is understood as well

 

Problem definition: The thickness of an insert is defined to be the DV. Two stress constraints are defined. The objective is a stress minmax formulation.

 

Question:  I am unable to figure out whether the large constraint violation % implies a critical issue. If yes, how does one rectify the problem?

 

Iteration Subcase     Variable  Grid/Elem ID   Value
---------------------------------------------------------
    0      1 MaxDisp                  4712_Y  5.96215e-05
    0      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    4.50698e+07
    0      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    125.349
    1      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.67884e-05
    1      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.80622e+07
    1      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    90.3111
    2      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.72058e-05
    2      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.54572e+07
    2      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    77.286
    3      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.86367e-05
    3      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.52875e+07
    3      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    76.4375
    4      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.95676e-05
    4      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.51522e+07
    4      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    75.7608
    5      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  6.00593e-05
    5      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.50283e+07
    5      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    75.1417
    6      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  6.04046e-05
    6      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.49025e+07
    6      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    74.5125

 

Unable to find an attachment - read this blog

Find more posts tagged with