Explanation for very large maximum constraint violation % in the first iteration

User: "pshivashankar"
Altair Community Member
Updated by pshivashankar

Greetings,

 

I am performing a free-size optimization (iteration summary given below) and trying to understand the explanation behind maximum constraint violation %. So far the following is clear:

  • If constraint violation > 1% : status is V (violated)
  • If constraint violation < 1% : status is A (Active)
  • Large constraint violation % could mean that the constraint is too tight and that the problem itself is ill-defined.
  • the difference  between regular and soft convergence is understood as well

 

Problem definition: The thickness of an insert is defined to be the DV. Two stress constraints are defined. The objective is a stress minmax formulation.

 

Question:  I am unable to figure out whether the large constraint violation % implies a critical issue. If yes, how does one rectify the problem?

 

Iteration Subcase     Variable  Grid/Elem ID   Value
---------------------------------------------------------
    0      1 MaxDisp                  4712_Y  5.96215e-05
    0      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    4.50698e+07
    0      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    125.349
    1      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.67884e-05
    1      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.80622e+07
    1      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    90.3111
    2      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.72058e-05
    2      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.54572e+07
    2      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    77.286
    3      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.86367e-05
    3      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.52875e+07
    3      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    76.4375
    4      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  5.95676e-05
    4      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.51522e+07
    4      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    75.7608
    5      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  6.00593e-05
    5      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.50283e+07
    5      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    75.1417
    6      1 MaxDisp                  5566_Y  6.04046e-05
    6      0 ObjFun:Min(Max)EQATN        0    3.49025e+07
    6      0 MaxConstrViol(%)            0    74.5125

 

Unable to find an attachment - read this blog

Find more posts tagged with