How to manipulate superelements with DMIGMOD in OptiStruct


Table of Contents


Models

 

The models used in this article can be found here: Models


Use Case

Superelements are a very useful technique to simplify complex models. There are several benefits to using them such as reducing computational cost and runtime, improved model management, and security.

To maximize the advantages of superelements, OptiStruct has the DMIGMOD feature which allows you to modify, manipulate, and move an existing H3D superelement within your residual model. A few application examples are the layout of battery packs, tyre-and-wheel assembly in a car, seats in a plane, and agricultural machinery sub-systems.

This article explores the use cases and applications of DMIGMOD.

 

Format and Definition

DMIGMOD is represented within OptiStruct by the following format:

A screenshot of a white tableDescription automatically generated

Since it has multiple parameters and possible inputs, in this article we will highlight the most important ones. For a detailed description of each one of them, please refer to our documentation: https://help.altair.com/hwsolvers/os/topics/solvers/os/dmigmod_bulk_r.htm

 

- MTXNAME: Matrix name defined on ASSIGN,H3DDMIG

- SHF_____: All fields in the first line starting with the SHF prefix represent an ID shift for a particular entity of the superelement (grids, SPOINTs, elements, coordinate systems, …). This is useful if you need to simply renumber the superelement due to an ID conflict or if you plan to use the superelement several times in the residual model.

 

- GIDMAP + GIDn, GIDnA: Define mapped grid ID pairs. GIDMAP is to renumber the interface grid IDs such that they match the IDs used in the residual structure.

 

- RELOC + PAn, PBn: Use to reposition the superelement in the residual run, pointing grid ID pairs in the residual structure (PA1, PA2, PA3) and superelement (PB1, PB2, PB3). MIRROR flag can be used for reflecting the superelement.

A diagram of a structureDescription automatically generated

- GRDTOL: Defines the tolerance settings between matching residual and superelement grids. The default tolerance setting is 1E-15, OptiStruct will error out if this value is violated.

 

Example and Validation

As an example, we will use the following model, which can be found at the beginning of this article:

A red square with different colored squaresDescription automatically generated with medium confidence

The model consists of a modal analysis of a structure with four similar components attached to it that we will call instances (green, blue, purple, and gray components). These instances will be replaced by superelements with the DMIGMOD feature.

The process will be divided into 3 steps: running the full model as a reference, creating the superelement of only one instance (INST1), and running the reduced model with the superelement. To facilitate our job later, the interface nodes between the instances and the structure were renumbered as below:

A screenshot of a computer gameDescription automatically generated

 

Superelement Generation

In this step, we will create a superelement only for the green component (Instance 1).  For that, there are no extra or special inputs necessary, as it is done in a traditional reduction. ASETs will be defined at interface nodes and CBN method will be used with CMSMETH load collector. MODEL card is created to recover results later in the residual run. Refer to 02_Superelement_INST1\superelement_inst1.fem in the attached zip for more details.

A screenshot of a computerDescription automatically generated

 

Residual Run with DMIGMOD

 

For the residual run, we will import the 01_Full_Mesh\baseline_full_mesh.fem and delete all four instances of the model:

A red grid with white squaresDescription automatically generated

 

The next step is to import the superelement generated of Instance 1 four times since we will replace all four instances with the same superelement. This can be done through the ASSIGN, H3DDMIG entry as follows:

A screenshot of a computer programDescription automatically generated

Note that INST1, INST2, INST3, and INST4 are the matrix names that we will use to reference in DMIGMOD.

Now, INST1 superelement is the original one and does not require any modification. Using the DMIGMOD we will modify and reposition the other three superelements as follows:

 

For INST2:

The original nodes from the INST1 superelement need to be mapped with GIDMAP and then relocated with RELOC to INST2 position.

A screenshot of a computer gameDescription automatically generated

 

DMIGMOD

MTXNAME

INST2

SHFGID
2000001

SHFSPID
2000001

SHFSPID_F

SHFCID

SHFEID
2000001

SHFRID
2000001



+

GIDMAP

GID1

101

GID1A

201

GID2

102

GID2A

202

GID3

103

GID3A

203

 

+

GIDMAP

GID4

104

GID4A

204

 

 

 

 

 

+

RELOC

PA1

201

PA2

202

PA3

203

PB1

101

PB2

102

PB3

103

 

+

GRDTOL

ERREXT

WARN

TOLEXT

1E-1

 

 

 

 

 

 

For INST3 and INST4:

For the other two instances, the process is quite similar, adding only the MIRROR flag in RELOC line since we need to reflect them to the other side of the model.

A screenshot of a computerDescription automatically generated

 

DMIGMOD

MTXNAME

INST3

SHFGID
3000001

SHFSPID
3000001

SHFSPID_F

SHFCID

SHFEID
3000001

SHFRID
3000001



+

GIDMAP

GID1

101

GID1A

301

GID2

102

GID2A

302

GID3

103

GID3A

303

 

+

GIDMAP

GID4

104

GID4A

304

 

 

 

 

 

+

RELOC

PA1

301

PA2

302

PA3

303

PB1

101

PB2

102

PB3

103

MIRROR

+

GRDTOL

ERREXT

WARN

TOLEXT

1E-1

 

 

 

 

 

 

DMIGMOD

MTXNAME

INST4

SHFGID
4000001

SHFSPID
4000001

SHFSPID_F

SHFCID

SHFEID
4000001

SHFRID
4000001



+

GIDMAP

GID1

101

GID1A

401

GID2

102

GID2A

402

GID3

103

GID3A

403

 

+

GIDMAP

GID4

104

GID4A

404

 

 

 

 

 

+

RELOC

PA1

301

PA2

302

PA3

303

PB1

101

PB2

102

PB3

103

MIRROR

+

GRDTOL

ERREXT

WARN

TOLEXT

1E-1

 

 

 

 

 

 

In the deck, this will look like:

A screenshot of a computer programDescription automatically generated 

The solved model can be found in 03_Residual_DMIGMOD\residual_DMIGMOD.fem. In the .out file, it is possible to check if all superelements were successfully processed:

A screen shot of a computerDescription automatically generated

 

Validation with Full Mesh model

 

To validate the methodology and results, we can compare baseline_full_mesh.h3d with residual_DMIGMOD.h3d results.

 

Mode

Baseline Model - Full Mesh

Residual Model with DMIGMOD

Error (%)

1

16.48

15.91

3.5%

2

57.11

55.36

3.1%

3

70.40

69.70

1.0%

4

78.73

77.31

1.8%

5

80.82

80.44

0.5%

6

124.56

123.53

0.8%

7

192.78

192.00

0.4%

8

232.72

232.24

0.2%

9

410.06

409.85

0.1%

10

413.66

413.31

0.1%

 

 

Useful links

 

DMIGMOD

Direct Matrix Input (Superelements)

Superelement tutorial