Duplicate Id for particle-wall collision.

Hi Fatemeh,

Can you please let us know which version of EDEM are you using, also can you please try the below command

 

Thanks,

Prasad A

Hi,

The IDs correspond to particles and geometry elements, not just geometries. If you have a particle contacting multiple triangular faces of a geometry then you will see multiple values for the first ID but differing values for the second.

Richard 

Hi,

The IDs correspond to particles and geometry elements, not just geometries. If you have a particle contacting multiple triangular faces of a geometry then you will see multiple values for the first ID but differing values for the second.

Richard 

Thanks for your response.

That makes problem for deposition investigation.

Is there a way to constrain the code to only save a particle's ID per geometry contact/face while ignoring other faces (e.g. if a particle contacts more than one face)?

Thanks for your response.

That makes problem for deposition investigation.

Is there a way to constrain the code to only save a particle's ID per geometry contact/face while ignoring other faces (e.g. if a particle contacts more than one face)?

The simplest option would be to just ignore duplicates in your own bit of Python code. Once you get your list of collisions, just ignore any that have a duplicate of the firstID, since in a p-g collision the particle is always the first element. The downside of this approach is that if a particles contacts multiple geometries, not elements, then you would be discarding some data. A more rigorous approach might be to get all the element (or triangle) IDs per geometry and then remove duplicates after taking these into account:

Richard